Resources list
Low code
TAM

Automating without breaking the existing: large enterprise case study

Team Rokodo
3
-
21.10.2026
Automating without breaking the existing: large enterprise case study

Process automation has become a competitive necessity in insurance. Yet most mid-sized and large insurers still operate on complex technology foundations: legacy ERPs, heterogeneous APIs, proprietary connectors accumulated through decades of mergers and acquisitions. The temptation to demolish everything and rebuild from scratch is strong. This is a major strategic and financial mistake.

Operational reality demands a different approach: intelligent orchestration. Rather than replacement, the goal is to augment existing systems with automation layers that coexist with current infrastructure, never disrupting critical business processes.

What Is Big Bang Automation?

Big bang approaches rely on classical IT transformation logic: identify legacy systems as obstacles, decommission them entirely, and replace them with unified new infrastructure. In insurance, this means shutting down old ERPs, migrating all contract data, rewriting interfaces, and relaunching all operational flows simultaneously.

This strategy carries substantial risks: service interruptions, data loss, operational chaos for months, exponential costs. According to a 2023 Deloitte study, "all-in-one" modernization projects in financial services exceed their initial budgets by an average of 40% and face delays of 8 to 12 months.

What Is Intelligent Orchestration?

Intelligent orchestration is a progressive integration strategy that preserves existing systems while connecting them to new, automated business layers. These layers operate at the surface of the IT infrastructure, never altering the core where critical transactional data resides.

The architecture rests on three principles: preservation of existing systems, API-first connections to new workflows, and complete processing traceability. McKinsey (2022) terms this approach "progressive modularization" and identifies it as the most common model among high-performing insurers in digital transformation.

Difference 1: Project Lifecycle Approach

Big bang: immediate rupture

  • Projects concentrated in time with a single cutover date
  • All teams mobilized simultaneously over 12 to 24 months
  • Risk of systemic failure if migration falters

Orchestration: progressive rollout

  • Automation deployed by business domain (claims, underwriting, indemnification)
  • Existing teams progressively enhanced without losing their foundation
  • Each new layer validated before proceeding, reducing risk exposure

Reference: Gartner (2023) explicitly recommends the progressive approach for groups with over 1,000 technology staff.

Difference 2: Compliance and Audit Impact

Big bang: regulatory uncertainty window

  • Fragmented traceability during transition, risk of GDPR and Solvency II violations
  • New interfaces and databases still stabilizing at audit time
  • Requires regulatory exemption or increases external audit burden

Orchestration: continuous and traceable compliance

  • Each automation layer has native logging and control checkpoints
  • Legacy systems continue certifying transactional data; new layers merely execute pre-validated decisions
  • Continuous audit possible without disruption

Orchestration ensures that every indemnification request remains traceable end-to-end, from source data to payment, meeting insurance governance standards.

Difference 3: Value Curve and ROI

Big bang: deferred gains

  • No measurable improvement for 18-24 months
  • Positive ROI expected from year 3, contingent on stabilization
  • Need to fund both existing and new systems in parallel during transition

Orchestration: quarter-one ROI visibility

  • First automated processes (e.g., indemnification) accelerated within 90 days
  • Processing time improvements immediately observable (15 days reduced to 48 hours for online claims)
  • Transition costs distributed and justified by immediate gains

According to Deloitte (2024), insurers adopting progressive orchestration report 35% operational productivity improvement in year one, compared to 15% average for big bang approaches once stabilized.

Difference 4: Skills Management and Organization

Big bang: temporary structural disruption

  • Legacy teams redeployed to new infrastructure (possible skill degradation)
  • Massive recruitment of specialists for target stack
  • Elevated turnover risk from perceived obsolescence of legacy skills

Orchestration: reinforcement of existing capabilities

  • Legacy teams retain governance and operations scope
  • New skills added to manage orchestration layers (low-code, API management, RPA)
  • Better talent retention and operational continuity

Orchestration transforms teams by augmenting their tools, not replacing them.

Difference 5: Scalability and Business Flexibility

Big bang: rigid architectural scalability

  • Once deployed, infrastructure is stable but difficult to adapt to rapid business evolution
  • Adding new processes requires heavy redeployment or reconfiguration
  • Slow release cycles (quarterly or annual)

Orchestration: progressive and reactive scalability

  • New automation layers deployable independently
  • Adaptive workflows that adjust to business needs without ERP modification
  • Fast release cycles (weekly), in-flight testing possible

Concrete example: during health crises or peak claims periods (storms, flooding), orchestration instantly activates parallel workflows without overloading the core system.

Difference 6: Total Cost of Ownership Over Five Years

Big bang: front-loaded investment

  • Initial budget: EUR 10-15 million for mid-cap insurers
  • Two years of parallel costs (old and new systems)
  • Post-deployment incidents and costly remediation

Orchestration: smoothed and justified investment

  • Initial budget: EUR 3-5 million for equivalent capability
  • Additional investments justified by already-realized gains
  • Maintenance of legacy systems progressively reduced as automation expands

Gartner (2023) estimates that orchestration's five-year total cost is 30 to 40% lower than big bang for organizations with 500 to 5,000 operational staff.